Subscribe free

Gold vs. Silver: Structural Differences for Canadian Buyers

The verifiable structural differences between gold and silver bullion in Canada: GST/HST purity thresholds, value density, demand drivers, dealer premiums, market liquidity and the gold-to-silver ratio, with no recommendation on which metal to buy.

By Gold in Canada, editorial desk9 min read

We may earn a commission from companies named on this page. How we get paid

One gold coin beside a larger stack of silver coins, showing the value density difference between the two metals
In this article 9 sections
  1. At a glance: six structural differences
  2. GST/HST purity threshold
  3. Value density: why a dollar of silver takes up more space than a dollar of gold
  4. What drives demand: investment and jewellery for gold, industry for silver
  5. Premiums over spot: a structural reason silver often costs more as a percentage
  6. Liquidity and market size
  7. The gold to silver ratio: what it measures, and what it does not
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Sources

Last reviewed: 11 November 2026. Sources are linked in the text.

Gold and silver both trade as bullion, but they are not the same product structurally. This guide covers how each is taxed, how much value each packs into a given weight, what drives demand for each, how dealer pricing differs, and market liquidity, plus the gold to silver price ratio and what it does and does not tell a buyer.

This is educational material only. It does not say which metal is better, and it is not personalized investment advice. Every figure below is dated and linked to a primary source: a government page, a mint or market body’s own published data, or a recognized industry survey. No competing gold or silver retail blog is used as a source here.

At a glance: six structural differences

Each row is explained below, with sources.

Structural dimensionGoldSilver
GST/HST exempt purity threshold99.5%99.9%
Density19.3 g per cm³10.5 g per cm³
Spot price, 11 November 2026US$4,040.56 per troy ozUS$52.21 per troy oz
Share of 2025 demand from industrial/technology useAbout 6.5%About 58%
Typical premium over spot, as a percentageGenerally lowerGenerally higher
LBMA market turnover, 12-week average to 16 Oct 2026US$964.17 billionUS$129.69 billion

GST/HST purity threshold

Under the Excise Tax Act, a “precious metal” is a bar, ingot, coin or wafer of gold, silver or platinum, refined to at least 99.5% purity for gold and platinum, and at least 99.9% for silver. A coin must also be issued by a government authority and usable as currency. A supply meeting this definition is a financial service, generally exempt from GST/HST (Canada Revenue Agency, GST/HST Memorandum 17-1, “Definition of Financial Instrument”, July 2026 version, paragraphs 29 to 32, checked 11 November 2026).

The bar is not the same for both metals: silver needs 99.9% purity versus gold’s 99.5% for the same exemption. Standard investment-grade bullion for both clears its own threshold easily (both the Gold and Silver Maple Leaf are 99.99% pure), so this rarely changes a buying decision, but it is a real difference in the statutory text. A lower-purity or unusual product should be checked against the correct threshold. Resale under this rule is separate from income tax owed on a gain, which the Income Tax Act governs instead (same memorandum, paragraph 31).

Value density: why a dollar of silver takes up more space than a dollar of gold

Gold’s density is 19.3 grams per cubic centimetre; silver’s is 10.5 (Royal Society of Chemistry periodic table entries for gold and silver, checked 11 November 2026). Gold’s price per troy ounce is also a large multiple of silver’s: on 11 November 2026, gold traded at US$4,040.56 and silver at US$52.21 (Trading Economics, gold and silver, checked 11 November 2026). At the Bank of Canada’s most recently posted daily rate, 1 US dollar equalled 1.4181 Canadian dollars on 10 November 2026 (Bank of Canada, Daily exchange rates, checked 11 November 2026), which puts gold at roughly CAD$184 per gram and silver at roughly CAD$2.38 per gram that day.

Together these produce a genuine structural fact: a fixed dollar amount of silver is heavier and bulkier than gold. CAD$10,000 of gold was about 54 grams and 2.8 cubic centimetres, smaller than a sugar cube; the same amount in silver was about 4.2 kilograms and 400 cubic centimetres, close to a can of a beverage: roughly 77 times the weight and 140 times the volume. These figures move daily with spot prices and the exchange rate, but the ratio between the two metals’ value density is far steadier, since it depends mainly on the price gap between them. Storing, insuring, transporting or shipping a given dollar amount of silver generally costs more and takes more room than gold.

What drives demand: investment and jewellery for gold, industry for silver

Gold and silver demand are not pulled by the same forces, and each metal’s own industry survey publishes the breakdown. The World Gold Council’s full-year 2025 data splits gold demand of 4,999.4 tonnes into investment (bars, coins, ETFs) at 2,175.3 tonnes (43.5%); jewellery at 1,638.0 tonnes (32.8%); central banks at 863.3 tonnes (17.3%); and technology, covering electronics and other industrial and dental use, at 322.8 tonnes (6.5%) (World Gold Council, Gold Demand Trends, Q4 and Full Year 2025, checked 11 November 2026). Industrial and technology use is a small slice of gold demand; investment, jewellery and central banks together account for roughly 94%.

Silver’s split looks very different. The Silver Institute’s World Silver Survey 2026 reports total silver demand of 1,130.6 million ounces in 2025, of which industrial fabrication, covering electronics (including solar cells), brazing alloys and solders, and other industrial uses, was 657.4 million ounces, about 58.1% (Silver Institute, World Silver Survey 2026, checked 11 November 2026). Industrial demand is a minority share for gold but a majority share for silver, so swings in electronics or solar manufacturing can move silver’s price in ways gold’s does not echo, and the reverse holds for central bank or jewellery buying. Neither survey says which metal performs better; both simply show where demand comes from.

Premiums over spot: a structural reason silver often costs more as a percentage

The spot price is the quoted market value of one troy ounce of unfabricated metal; dealers do not sell at spot. The Royal Canadian Mint’s own guide explains the mechanism: “there are costs involved in the manufacturing, transportation and delivery of bullion, so dealers will typically charge a premium on top of the spot price to cover those costs,” and “smaller bars and coins will have higher premiums than larger ones, reflecting the higher cost of production relative to their bullion weight” (Royal Canadian Mint, “Buying Precious Metals” guide (PDF), checked 11 November 2026).

The Mint’s guide does not compare gold’s premium to silver’s, but the mechanism has a clear consequence. Striking, packaging, distributing and authenticating a coin costs about the same dollar amount whether it holds gold or silver. Since silver’s spot price is a small fraction of gold’s, that fixed cost is a much bigger share of a silver coin’s price than a similarly produced gold coin. This is the same reasoning applied to the Gold and Silver Maple Leaf coins on this site: silver bullion tends to carry a higher premium over spot as a percentage than gold bullion of a similar type, even from the same mint at the same security standard. Premiums move with conditions and differ by dealer; use this site’s melt-value calculator to check a product against a dealer’s asking price.

Liquidity and market size

Gold’s bullion market is substantially larger than silver’s by traded value. The London Bullion Market Association, which oversees the London over-the-counter market used to set global benchmark prices, publishes its own trade data: for the 12 weeks ending 16 October 2026, average daily trading value was US$964.17 billion for gold versus US$129.69 billion for silver, roughly 7.4 times silver’s dollar value (London Bullion Market Association, LBMA Daily Trade Reporting Data, checked 11 November 2026). A separate LBMA clearing figure shows a similar gap: average daily value transferred in August 2026 was US$81.8 billion for gold versus US$11.4 billion for silver (London Bullion Market Association, Newsroom clearing statistics, checked 11 November 2026).

A larger, deeper market is generally associated with tighter spreads and easier execution, though the LBMA figures describe institutional wholesale trading, not Canadian retail dealer pricing. Gold is also more widely held by central banks and more consistently recognized across countries as a monetary asset, part of why its wholesale market is larger. This is a statement about market structure, not a claim that a larger market makes gold the better purchase for any buyer.

The gold to silver ratio: what it measures, and what it does not

The gold to silver ratio is gold’s spot price divided by silver’s spot price: how many troy ounces of silver one troy ounce of gold buys, at that moment. Using the spot prices cited above, the ratio on 11 November 2026 was approximately 77.4 to 1 (US$4,040.56 divided by US$52.21; Trading Economics, gold and silver pages, checked 11 November 2026). The ratio moves whenever either metal’s price moves relative to the other, so today’s figure will not hold tomorrow.

Some buyers use the ratio as one input when deciding how to split purchases. This guide does not do that, and does not suggest a high or low reading means either metal is “due” to move. The ratio reflects market pricing, not a fixed physical relationship between the metals; it has moved across a wide range over different periods, reflecting shifts in demand for each (investment, industrial, jewellery and central bank, as described above). A reader who sees it cited elsewhere as a trading signal should treat that as someone else’s interpretation, not a property of the number itself.

Frequently asked questions

Is gold or silver more volatile?

On a percentage basis, silver has tended to swing more widely than gold. Over the first nine months of 2026, the London Bullion Market Association’s own quarterly report shows gold’s trading range (low to high) at about 38.3% of its low, versus silver’s about 114.2%, roughly three times as wide (London Bullion Market Association, Precious Metals Market Report: Q3 2026, checked 11 November 2026). That fits the picture above: silver’s smaller, industrially exposed market tends to swing more sharply than gold’s larger, investment-driven market. This describes one period already past, not a prediction of what comes next.

Which is easier to store?

For the same dollar value, gold takes up far less space and weighs far less than silver, given the density and price-per-gram gap described above. Roughly CAD$10,000 of gold is a small handful of coins weighing about 54 grams; the same dollar amount in silver is about 4.2 kilograms, closer in bulk to a bag of sugar than a coin stack. A buyer holding a large dollar amount in silver will generally need more physical space and more robust storage than the same dollar amount in gold.

Which has the bigger market?

Gold’s, by a wide margin, measured by trading value. The LBMA’s own data puts average daily gold turnover at roughly 7.4 times silver’s dollar value over the 12 weeks ending 16 October 2026. Gold is also more heavily held by central banks and more uniformly recognized as a monetary asset. A bigger market is not, on its own, a reason to prefer one metal over the other; it is a fact about trading depth and recognition.

Should a beginner start with gold or silver?

This guide does not answer that: it depends on a buyer’s own goals, storage, budget and risk tolerance, none of which this guide knows. It can restate the tradeoffs above: gold needs 99.5% purity for GST/HST exemption, silver needs 99.9%; gold packs far more value into a given weight and volume, making it simpler to store and move; silver’s demand leans toward industrial use (about 58% in 2025) while gold’s leans toward investment, jewellery and central banks (about 94%); silver bullion tends to carry a higher premium over spot; and gold trades in a larger, more liquid market. None of this says which metal, or mix, fits a reader’s plan. For a decision specific to an individual’s finances, speak with a licensed financial professional.

Sources

All checked 11 November 2026 unless a document’s own internal date is shown.

About this byline

Gold in Canada is written by an editorial desk, not a single person. We are not advisers, and nothing here is personalized investment, tax or legal advice. Who writes this

Spotted an error? Tell us. We fix pages in place and say what changed.

First published Nov 17, 2026Updated Nov 17, 2026

The Spot Check

Plain-English notes on gold, silver and your RRSP and TFSA.

By subscribing, you agree to get emails, including sponsored messages, from Gold in Canada (Flaneur Ventures LLC, 2578 Broadway #676, New York, NY 10025, USA, hello@goldincanada.ca). Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.