In this article 9 sections
- What Canada’s anti-money-laundering rules actually require
- A verifiable address and a length of time in business
- Does the dealer publish its buy-back policy before you buy
- Third-party reputation signals: BBB, Google reviews and Trustpilot
- Industry association membership: checked, not assumed
- Price transparency: live pricing against spot, or call for a quote
- A short checklist
- FAQ
- Sources
Last reviewed: 11 November 2026. Sources are linked in the text.
Searches for a local gold or silver dealer usually carry an unspoken question: how do you know the shop behind the website, or the counter at the end of a strip mall, is trustworthy? We cannot answer that for any one business, since listings change and ownership turns over, and a wrong recommendation would do more harm than good. What we can do is lay out the factors that apply to any bullion dealer in Canada, in any city, so you can check them yourself before you hand over money. Every point below is something you can verify independently, using the dealer’s own disclosures and public, third-party sources, not our say-so.
What Canada’s anti-money-laundering rules actually require
A common assumption is that a legitimate bullion dealer must be “registered with FINTRAC as a money services business.” That is not quite right, and getting it precise changes what you can and cannot look up yourself. Under the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act, a business that buys or sells precious metals, precious stones or jewellery is regulated as a “dealer in precious metals and precious stones” (DPMS), a separate category from a “money services business” (MSB) (fintrac-canafe.canada.ca, checked 11 November 2026). DPMS obligations, including a compliance program, client identification, record keeping and transaction reporting, apply once a dealer buys or sells $10,000 CAD or more of precious metals, stones or jewellery in a single transaction; a dealer whose transactions are all smaller than that is not subject to these requirements at all (same source).
Here is the part that is easy to assume wrongly: unlike MSBs, which must register with FINTRAC before they operate and appear in a public, searchable Money Services Business Registry, DPMS are not required to register with FINTRAC at all, and there is no equivalent public DPMS registry. MSB registration covers a different set of services: foreign exchange dealing, remitting or transmitting funds, issuing or redeeming money orders, virtual currency dealing, and crowdfunding (fintrac-canafe.canada.ca and fintrac-canafe.canada.ca, both checked 11 November 2026). A dealer that only buys and sells physical bullion would not appear in that registry, and its absence there tells you nothing. If a dealer also advertises currency exchange alongside bullion, that specific service is the part you could check against the MSB registry. A registration, where one applies, also “does not indicate that FINTRAC endorses or licenses the business” (same source). Practically, a bullion dealer cannot show you a FINTRAC licence for its bullion side, because none exists; what you can reasonably ask is whether it has a compliance program and ID procedures in place, since those are real legal duties once it crosses $10,000, even without a public list to check the answer against.
A verifiable address and a length of time in business
A dealer that publishes a specific street address, rather than only a contact form, gives you something concrete: look the address up independently and see whether it resolves to a real commercial unit. For an online-only seller, the absence of any physical address at all is itself worth weighing.
You can also get a rough, independent read on how long a business has existed. Corporations Canada runs a free public search of federally incorporated businesses showing corporate status and incorporation date (ised-isde.canada.ca, checked 11 November 2026); it does not cover provincially incorporated businesses, for which Canada’s Business Registries portal links out to each province’s own registry (ised-isde.canada.ca, checked 11 November 2026). Treat this as a proxy, not proof: a changed trade name, a sole proprietorship, or incorporation under a different legal name will not necessarily show up cleanly, so a dealer’s own “since [year]” claim is still worth weighing against whatever the registry shows.
Does the dealer publish its buy-back policy before you buy
A dealer’s willingness to state, in writing and before a sale, what it will pay to buy a product back later is meaningful. Policies vary by seller in exactly the ways our review of banks and Costco.ca found: some sellers do not buy anything back, some only buy back their own stock with the original receipt, and some buy more broadly at a published spread off spot (see our comparison of banks, Costco and dedicated dealers for how differently that already plays out among large, well-known sellers). A dealer that cannot or will not describe its buy-back terms until after you have already bought is asking you to take more on faith than one that spells the terms out upfront, even if the terms themselves turn out to be modest.
Third-party reputation signals: BBB, Google reviews and Trustpilot
None of these signals is sufficient alone, and checking them together matters, since a review count or rating on one platform can be thin, old, or unrepresentative in ways a second platform may not share.
- Better Business Bureau: accreditation requires meeting eight published standards, including an operating track record (commonly six to twelve months, depending on the local BBB) and a letter rating of B or better (bbb.org, checked 11 November 2026). A business that skipped the fee-based accreditation process is not automatically suspect; what matters more is whether a BBB profile exists at all, what letter grade it shows, and what its complaint history says, accredited or not.
- Google reviews: useful for volume and recency, but check whether reviews are spread over years rather than clustered in a short burst, which can indicate a purchased batch rather than organic feedback.
- Trustpilot: calculates a “TrustScore” from review count, age and a weighting formula, and shows a “Verified Company” badge only once a business proves identity verification, a synced Google Business Profile, registered domain ownership, or bank account registration (corporate.trustpilot.com, checked 11 November 2026). Trustpilot states a business cannot pay to remove a genuine negative review, which is part of why a cluster of unresolved one-star reviews about the same issue carries more weight than an average score alone.
Industry association membership: checked, not assumed
We looked specifically for a Canadian trade association exclusively for bullion dealers and did not find one. The closest existing body is the Canadian Association of Numismatic Dealers (CAND), founded in 1975, a national non-profit whose membership “include[s] dealers, auction firms, publishers, show organizers, bullion specialists, supply manufacturers, and other professionals.” Every member agrees to a Code of Ethics, and CAND maintains “a formal process for addressing concerns involving member dealers and a performance fund that may offer some compensation in eligible cases when a member fails to meet their obligations” (cand.org, checked 11 November 2026), plus a public Find a Dealer directory. CAND’s scope is numismatics broadly, coins and paper money alongside bullion, not bullion exclusively, so membership is a reasonable positive signal of a baseline ethics commitment rather than proof a dealer specializes in bullion. Separately, the Royal Canadian Mint maintains its own directory of dealers registered to sell its BULLION DNA anti-counterfeiting product line (mint.ca, checked 11 November 2026); that is the Mint vouching for who can sell that specific authenticated product, not a general endorsement of a dealer’s overall practices.
Price transparency: live pricing against spot, or call for a quote
No government rule requires a seller to publish live pricing, so this is a practical check rather than a legal one. A dealer that shows a calculated price next to a current spot reference, with a separate published buy price and sell price, lets you work out the premium yourself at the moment you decide whether to buy. A dealer that requires you to call or message for a price removes that moment-of-purchase check; it is not proof of anything wrong on its own, since staff time and a fast-moving spot market both matter for smaller sellers, but it is a mild red flag worth weighing, especially if you cannot get even a rough indicative range without handing over contact information first. You can use the site’s own bullion premium calculator and gold and silver price calculator to check any seller’s quoted price against spot yourself, whatever that seller tells you about its own pricing.
A short checklist
- Does it describe how it handles client ID and large transactions? Legally required past $10,000 CAD, even with no public registry to check it against.
- Does it publish a verifiable street address, and does a registry search support how long it says it has operated?
- Does it publish a buy-back policy before you buy, not only on request afterward?
- Does it have a checkable profile on more than one of BBB, Google and Trustpilot, with complaints (if any) clustered around one repeated problem rather than scattered?
- Is it a CAND member or a Mint BULLION DNA dealer on top of the checks above, rather than instead of them?
- Can you see a live, calculated price against spot, or does getting any number require your contact details first?
FAQ
How do I know a bullion dealer is legitimate? No single check is conclusive, so use several together: a verifiable address and a registry record consistent with how long the dealer says it has operated, a buy-back policy published before you buy, a checkable reputation across more than one platform rather than just one, and pricing you can measure against spot yourself. A dealer handling $10,000 CAD or more in a transaction is legally required to verify your identity and keep records under FINTRAC’s rules, but there is no public registry to confirm that compliance independently, so asking the dealer directly how it handles this is reasonable.
Should I buy in person or online? Both are normal in Canada, and the checks above apply to either. In person lets you inspect the product and the premises before paying. Online can offer wider selection and easier price comparison, but shifts more diligence onto delivery insurance, signature-required shipping, and the seller’s stated handling of a shipment that arrives damaged or short. Neither channel is inherently more trustworthy; the seller’s disclosures and reputation matter more than where the transaction happens.
What red flags should make me walk away? Pricing you cannot get without first providing contact information or booking a call; no published buy-back terms and no willingness to describe them when asked; no verifiable street address at all; a reputation profile with no history, or with unresolved complaints clustered on one issue (non-delivery, refused refunds, pressure to decide immediately); and any request to pay in a form designed to avoid a paper trail. None alone proves dishonesty, but more than one together is reason to keep looking.
Do I need ID to buy bullion in Canada? It depends how you pay. Under FINTRAC’s rules, a dealer must verify your identity only if you pay $10,000 CAD or more in cash in a single transaction, or in linked cash payments totalling that much within 24 hours, and must then file a Large Cash Transaction Report within 15 calendar days (fintrac-canafe.canada.ca, checked 11 November 2026). The same threshold applies to a large virtual-currency payment. Below that cash threshold, or paying by card, e-transfer or wire, FINTRAC’s rules do not themselves require ID, though a dealer may still ask for it as its own store policy; that is a private choice, not a federal requirement. A dealer must also verify identity on any transaction, of any size, it judges suspicious enough to report. This is the general rule as FINTRAC publishes it; a specific dealer’s in-store practice may be stricter.
Sources
- FINTRAC, “Dealers in precious metals and precious stones,” https://fintrac-canafe.canada.ca/re-ed/dpms-eng, accessed 11 November 2026.
- FINTRAC, “When to verify the identity of persons and entities: dealers in precious metals and precious stones,” https://fintrac-canafe.canada.ca/guidance-directives/client-clientele/client/dpms-eng, guidance effective 1 June 2021, accessed 11 November 2026.
- FINTRAC, “Reporting large cash transactions to FINTRAC,” https://fintrac-canafe.canada.ca/guidance-directives/transaction-operation/lctr-doie/lctr-doie-eng.php, accessed 11 November 2026.
- FINTRAC, “Register your money services business” and “Money Services Business Registry,” https://fintrac-canafe.canada.ca/msb-esm/reg-eng, accessed 11 November 2026.
- FINTRAC, “Conducting transactions with a money services business,” https://fintrac-canafe.canada.ca/public/businesses-entreprises-eng, accessed 11 November 2026.
- Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, “Search for a Federal Corporation,” https://ised-isde.canada.ca/cc/lgcy/fdrlCrpSrch.html, accessed 11 November 2026.
- Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, “Canada’s Business Registries,” https://ised-isde.canada.ca/cbr-rec/en/search, accessed 11 November 2026.
- Better Business Bureau, “BBB Accreditation Standards,” https://www.bbb.org/business/accreditation/standards, accessed 11 November 2026.
- Trustpilot, “Trustpilot Trust Centre,” https://corporate.trustpilot.com/trust, accessed 11 November 2026.
- Canadian Association of Numismatic Dealers, “About” and “Find a Dealer,” https://cand.org/about/, accessed 11 November 2026.
- Royal Canadian Mint, “Bullion Dealers,” https://www.mint.ca/en/bullion/bullion-dealers, accessed 11 November 2026.
- Gold in Canada, “Buying gold/silver at a bank or Costco vs. a bullion dealer,” https://goldincanada.ca/banks-costco-vs-dealer/, accessed 11 November 2026.
About this byline
Gold in Canada is written by an editorial desk, not a single person. We are not advisers, and nothing here is personalized investment, tax or legal advice. Who writes this
Spotted an error? Tell us. We fix pages in place and say what changed.





